Ah, but did my hackles ever bristle!
S&J is still the best RTD script, save Utopia, for the series... I dug it from day one and still don't mind it.
The only constructive criticism I can offer on the commentary itself would be that the commentating got a little off track a lot of times... however given you can only say so much about what's going on at a given moment, that's not an entirely bad thing. Nevertheless a little more focus might be a good thing.
Oh, and as far as Warren's remark of me being "a rock of sobriety in [your] drunken love for the show", well, Warren didn't see my complete lack of sobriety at either of the series 3 parties. =)
But yes, although you guys enjoy the whimsy far more than I, it's not like I completely hate it... there are times when it's all good. John Simm's OTT Master for instance I thought was brilliant and fun and I enjoyed it.